Skip to Content

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Wisconsin Dells – Top 9 Pizzas

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Wisconsin Dells – Top 9 Pizzas

There is no pizza without cheese, and there’s no better cheese than Wisconsin Cheese.  As Wisconsin is nicknamed ‘America’s Dairyland’, is there anywhere better to enjoy pizza? There are a bunch of options of where to find the best pizza in Wisconsin Dells. It all depends on what kind of pizza joint you’re searching for.

An array of these amazing pizza places in Wisconsin Dells offer create-your-own-pizza options, with tons of topping choices. Pick from thin or thick crusts, classic mozzarella, or the legendary Wisconsin cheese.

Whether you’re looking for a family-friendly restaurant or a local pizza joint, we’ve got you covered. Choose any one of these Wisconsin Dells pizza restaurants and dine in or take out, plus some of these great pizza restaurants in Wisconsin Dells even deliver.

We’ve searched around and discovered some of the best pizza restaurants in Wisconsin Dells. Check out these nine restaurants for the best pizza in Wisconsin Dells.

Beer sample at Wisconsin Dells Brewing

1. Moosejaw Pizza & Dells Brewing Co.

Moosejaw Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Wisconsin Dells. Their delivery cars drive around with a giant moose on the roof. It’s impossible to miss! If you have ever heard of one pizza restaurant in Wisconsin Dells, it most likely was Moosejaw.

The Moosejaw’s specialty has got to be their Meathead pizza. Covered in pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, regular bacon, and tons of cheese, it’s absolutely delicious. You’ve also gotta try one of Moosejaw’s locally brewed beers. They have 12 microbrews constantly on tap. Pick a pint or taste your way through the 12 Beer Sampler.

As well as pizza, there are calzones and a large selection of burgers, wraps, and sandwiches. There’s also a Mini-Moose Menu, perfect for kids. If you’re searching for the best breakfast in Wisconsin Dells, Moosejaw does an All-You-Can-Eat Breakfast Buffet on the weekend.

  • Is delivery available? Yes
  • View Menu 
  • Address: 110 Wisconsin Dells Pkwy S., Wisconsin Dells

2. The Pizza Pub

The Pizza Pub is another strong contender for the best pizza in Wisconsin Dells. The Pizza Pub prides itself on its secret pizza sauce, which dates back to 1983. Try their signature Pizza Pub Special, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, green peppers, and onion.

The Pizza Pub is perfect if you’re undecided on what to have. This is more than just a pizza joint. They have just about everything. Their 50-item soup and salad bar will leave you spoiled for choice. In addition to create-your-own pizzas, they also do burgers, sandwiches, and wraps.

  • Is delivery available? Yes
  • View Menu 
  • Address: 737 Superior Street, Wisconsin Dells

3. Dells Pizza Lab

Dells Pizza Lab is an incredible pizza emporium. This pizza lab specializes in create-your-own personal pizzas. To say there are a lot of toppings to choose from would be an understatement. They have literally everything you could possibly want on a pizza.

Just check out their pizza menu, it’s full of flavors. Choose from seven different sauces, including garlic butter and spicy red sauce. Then “Get Cheesy” with mozzarella, cheddar, feta, Cesar blend, provolone, or blue cheese. Pick your meat, veg, and a final drizzle of something nice. There are also a bunch of gluten-free options as well. All their pizza doughs are made fresh and cooked in a stone-hearth oven. If you don’t want pizza, you can also create-your-own salad, with all the same toppings.

They might just have the best pizza in Wisconsin Dells…if you can decide on the toppings!

  • Is delivery available? Yes
  • View Menu 
  • Address: 332 State Highway 13, Wisconsin Dells

Related Article: Best Restaurants in Wisconsin Dells

4. Pizza Villa

Located just off the downtown strip, Pizza Villa is a fantastic yet unassuming pizza restaurant. We’d go as far as to say it’s a bit of a hidden gem. Explore Wisconsin Dells downtown shops, then pop in for a pizza slice.

Pizza Villa has both crispy thin or pan-style crust pizzas. The Villa Special is served with Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and black olive.

They serve all the delicious standard appetizers. Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings, and Wisconsin Cheese Curds are all perfect for while you wait for your pizza to arrive.

  • Is delivery available? No, pick up only
  • Address: 1455 Wisconsin Dells Pkwy, Wisconsin Dells

5. Sarento’s

If you’re looking for a more traditional, gourmet pizza joint, Sarento’s is for you. Sarento’s serves up one of the best pizzas in Wisconsin Dells for families. This pizza joint is located inside teh Wilderness Resort, one of the best waterpark hotels in Wisconsin Dells.

Sarento’s pizzas come in thin or hand-tossed and in either 12 or 14 inches. Their pizzas are more traditional than other local joints. The Spicy Gorgonzola is bound to delight any cheese lover, while their Greek pizza is perfect for vegetarians. You can also build your own pizza to make it just to your liking.

If you are not in the mood for pizza, there are a variety of other options. A selection of fish dishes or the New England Clam Chowder may satisfy your taste buds. There’s also a Kids 12 & Under menu with a couple of great dishes.

  • Is delivery available? Yes (within a 6-mile radius)
  • View Menu 
  • Address: 441 Wisconsin Dells Pkwy S., Wisconsin Dells

6. The Green Owl Pizza

Located on Lake Delton, The Green Owl is a family-owned pizza restaurant. This is a good spot if you want lake views and great pizza.

All of The Green Owl’s pizzas are made from 100% Wisconsin mozzarella. You might go for the pizza, but the cheesy bread is a surprise highlight. Make sure you also leave room for dessert, as their peanut butter cheesecake is heavenly.

  • Is delivery available? No delivery
  • View Menu 
  • Address: 231 E Durkee Street, Wisconsin Dells

7. Luigi’s Pizza

Located at the Chula Vista Resort (one of the best Waterpark Hotels in Wisconsin dells), Luigi’s is the go-to place for pizza in the area. If you’re staying at the resort and are feeling hungry, why not order pizza? Peruse the pizza menu and order right to your room. After a busy day exploring all the things to do in Wisconsin Dells we often order pizza to be delivered to our hotel.

You can build your own pizza or pick one of Luigi’s specialty pizzas. Meat lovers will devour the BBQ Chicken and Luigi’s Supreme pizzas. Or opt for the Garden Vegetable pizza or Luigi’s House Salad if you’re looking for a vegetarian pizza.

  • Is delivery available? Yes
  • View Menu 
  • Address:  1000 Chula Vista Pkwy, Wisconsin Dells

8. Dells Bistro

They may not have a big menu, but what they do offer is fantastic food. Many drop by Dells Bistro in the morning for a bagel or croissant sandwiches. Dells Bistro is also well known for its innovative desserts. Their Bubble Waffles are legendary.

They also make five scrumptious pizzas. Try the Meatlovers, Veggie, Buffalo Chicken, Supreme, or From the Farm. Select their specialty white garlic sauce, and you won’t be disappointed. Or, if you’re in a rush, grab a quick pizza slice to go.

  • Is delivery available? No, but carryout is available.
  • Address:  126 Broadway, Wisconsin Dells

9. Buffalo Phil’s Pizza & Grille

For one of the best pizza joints in Wisconsin Dells to take the kids, visit Buffalo Phil’s. For some fun served alongside your slices of pizza, head to Buffalo Phil’s, which is a super kid-friendly restaurant, and proud of it. Their pride and joy are the enormous LEGO brick city that children absolutely love. The toy train that moves through the LEGO city will even deliver your food. Buffalo Phil’s is an instant crowd-pleaser.

Their pizza crusts are all homemade and served with Wisconsin-made local cheese. Phil’s Cheesesteak Pizza is an absolute feast. There’s even a Taco Pizza, perfect for lovers of pizza and Mexican food. As well as pizzas, they also do rotisserie chicken, burgers, wraps, and pasta dishes.

  • Is delivery available? Carry out orders only
  • View Menu 
  • Address: 150 Gasser Road, Wisconsin Dells

Good Chain Pizza Places in Wisconsin Dells

  • Rosati’s specializes in Chicago-style pizza, both thin crust and deep-dish pizza. They also use mozzarella from Wisconsin. Delivery is available.
  • Uno Pizzeria & Grill is a family-friendly chain specializing in Chicago-style deep-dish pizza. They do offer delivery.
  • Pizza Hut, an internationally known restaurant, serves its signature pan pizza along with all of the things you’d expect. Get pizza delivered right to your hotel room.
  • Domino’s is another popular multinational pizza restaurant. Domino’s is well renowned for its quick delivery service.
  • Pizza Ranch is one of the best pizza chains in the Midwest. The Wisconsin Dells branch does not offer delivery. That’s ok because the buffet is more fun anyway.

Where do you think is the best pizza in Wisconsin Dells?

Before heading out for the day, we suggest going out for a big hearty breakfast. Here are our picks for the best breakfast in Wisconsin Dells. If you visit during the winter or have a rainy day, consider grabbing a pint at one of these breweries in Wisconsin Dells.

Make sure to check out some of our other Wisconsin Dells articles: best waterpark hotels in Wisconsin Dells, Kalahari Resort review, and things to do in Wisconsin Dells.