Elvie vs. Elvie Stride, which one is better? Are you torn between the original Elvie breast pump and the brand new Elvie Stride? Both Elvie hands-free breast pumps are great. I’ve used them both as an exclusively pumping mother. Click here to check to see if your insurance will give you a free Elvie Stride or how much an upgrade will cost.
Here is a little about me and why you should keep reading. Hi, I’m Hannah. I am an exclusively pumping mother of two. I exclusively pump with the original Elvie, except once, maybe twice a day. I use my Spectra Gold (usually at the end of the night before bed). My first child was born in November 2019, and my second child was born in July 2021.
I wanted to try the Elvie Stride to see if the suction was any better and if it did a better job emptying my breasts than the original Elvie breast pump. Plus, I wanted to write this Elvie vs. Elvie Stride article and compare them side by side. So here we are! Click here to read my full Elvie Stride review.
I hope after reading this article, you’ll be able to decide which Elvie breast pump is best for you. If you’re looking for more tips and support, make sure to join the Elvie Stride Facebook group here.
Related Article: Must Have Baby Registry Items 2021
Elvie Pump Price
Both Elvie breast pumps are on the pricier side, but if you travel or are a busy mom who can’t be attached to the wall, they are worth every penny.
- Original Elvie Pump Price: $499 for a set with no insurance (cheaper options may be available or free based on your insurance), $249 single hub option
- Elvie Stride Price: $249 for a set with no insurance (cheaper options may be available or free based on your insurance)
Does Insurance Cover the Elvie Breast Pump?
This all depends on your insurance. The Elvie Stride is currently covered at 100% by Tricare and most other healthcare plans. Click here to check to see if your insurance will cover all or part of the cost. The Elvie Stride is being marked as an Insurance Pump and is currently only sold through durable medical equipment partners of Elvie (basically, it’s not available at Target, etc.). Here is our detailed guide on how to get a free breast pump through insurance. It’s crazy easy and only takes a minute!
All you have to do is provide them with your email and your basic insurance details. The company will then let you know what breast pumps your insurance will cover and if there are any upgrade options. If the Elvie Stride isn’t an option for you or you don’t have insurance, you can purchase it at full price from the listed companies. That is what I did. I purchased my Elvie Stride from Aeroflow.
To give you an idea of upgrade pricing, on my most recent pregnancy (this was before the Elvie Stride was on the market), my insurance gave me the option of the Spectra S2 for free ( I already own this as it was the breast pump I got through insurance with my first child), a Spectra S1 for a $35 upgrade, a Spectra Gold for $75 (this is what I choose), or the original Elvie double pump for a $250 upgrade ( I already owned it).
Most insurance companies will cover all or part of an electric breast pump for each pregnancy. My insurance tells me which websites I can order from, and from there, I provide my insurance details, and they let me know my breast pump options and if there are any upgrade options. Make sure to read our how to get a free breast pump through insurance guide.
Related – The Carseat that will change your life! Carseat & Stroller in One
I have tried a TON of bras. Super tight ones work for me. Get 20% off your order with our code GETTINGSTAMPED20
The Ceres Chill is a game-changer for those moms that pump at work or when you are pumping while out of the house and need to store their fresh breastmilk.
I have tried several bags, and this one is by far the best. I really like this bag holds all my breast pump supplies for the day, has a cooler, and it is affordable!
Noise – Which Elvie pump is louder?
The Elvie Stride is for sure louder than the original Elvie breast pump. However, it is still a really quiet breast pump, in my opinion. If you were working at your desk in a cubical, I don’t think the neighboring cubical could hear it.
I do feel you can hear the milk drop into the collection cups a lot more with the original Elvie than with the Elvie Stride.
Parts – Which Elvie pump has fewer parts to wash?
The Elvie Stride has one less part that has to be washed every time.
- Original Elvie Pump – Has five parts (per side) that have to be washed after every use.
- Elvie Stride- Has four parts (per side) that have to be washed after every use. The cup seal (technically part #5) doesn’t need to be removed for normal cleaning. It can stay on the cup front.
I wash them in hot water with dawn soap and use this bottle brush. For first-time use, make sure to sanitize the washable parts. The same goes for bottles, pacifiers, etc. You should always sanitize them before using them. I don’t sanitize after every use, some people do, and that is up to them. I use these sanitizer bags, each bag can be used 20 times, and they are sold in a pack. I feel like they are a good deal. Whenever I am traveling, I always sanitize all parts & bottles, as I don’t know the water and don’t want to risk getting my child sick.
I always travel with this collapsible sink. Sorry, but hotel sinks gross me out…I can’t wash my bottles in there, lol.
Related Article – Is the $1,500 SNOO Bassinet Really Worth It?
Which Elvie pump is stronger?
The Elvie Stride is stronger than the Elvie pump.
- Orginal Elvie Pump – 220 mmHg
- Elive Stride – 270 mmHg
Noticeable – Which Elvie pump is more noticeable while wearing?
The Elvie Stride is definitely louder, but it is not LOUD LOUD. You wouldn’t be able to hear it if you had a TV on or office chatter. The Elvie pump is much quieter, but I do feel you hear the milk trickle down into the collection cup where you don’t hear this with the Elvie Stride.
Battery – Which Elvie pump battery lasts longer?
They are equal in battery life and charging time.
- Elvie Stride Battery – A full battery will last about five 30-minute pump sessions and takes two hours to charge when fully dead.
- Original Elvie Battery – A full battery will last about five 30-minute pump sessions and takes two hours to charge when fully dead.
Size – Which Elvie pump is bigger?
Side by side, they are almost identical in size. You can’t really tell the difference between the two breast pumps, but on paper, the original Elvie pump is larger.
- Elvie Stride Specs
- Dimensions: 4.6′” (L) x 2.6″(W) X 1.7″(H)
- Weight: 1.2 lbs
- Elvie Pump Specs
- Dimensions:5″(L) x 4.3″(W) x 2.7″(H)
- Weight: 7.9 oz (for one breast pump)
They both can be linked to the Elvie app, where you can control the pump. Change intensity, turn it on & off, see how long you have been pumping, store pumping sessions, etc.
Which breast pump replacement parts are cheaper?
Both the Elvie Pump and Elvie Stride have parts that need to be replaced about every six months and after long storage between children.
- Elvie Pump parts to replace:
- Elvie Stride parts to replace:
Both breast pumps have the same warranty, which is a 2-year warranty on the pump motor and 90 days on the accessories. I have had to deal with Elvie’s customer service, and they have been great. I have reached out to them via email and Instagram message, and both responded within 24 hours.
Click Here To See If You Qualify For A FREE Elvie Stride Breast Pump
Other Must-Have Items for Breastfeeding & Exclusively Pumping Mothers
- Best Elvie Pumping Bra – I have tried a TON. For me, super tight ones work. You can also purchase it directly here and use our codeGETTINGSTAMPED20 for 20% off your order (non-sale items). If I am in a pinch, a sports bra will work.
- Best Elvie Pump Bag – I have tried several bags, and some have been better than others, and some just sucked. I really like this bag, the GOGOSO pumping bag with a cooler from Amazon. It holds all my breast pump supplies for the day, and it is affordable!
- Best Bottle Drying Rack – It’s super cheap and compact. I have one in my suitcase for travel, two in my kitchen, and one in my cabin.
- Nipple Cream – Don’t forget to put this on every time! I have used all different brands, and they all have been fine. I just most recently bought the one linked there and really liked it.
- LaVie warming Lactation Massager – This thing warms & massages which helps improve milk flow and makes pumping faster. It REALLY helps with clogged ducts and engorgement. I am speaking from a painful experience. I have two of these, but you can buy just one and switch sides.
- Breast pads – Again, any brand will work, I typically get this cheap brand from Target, and it does the job. NOTE I am not a big leaker.
- Hot & Cold therapy packs – For under $10, these are great because they can be thrown in the freezer for cool relief and put in the microwave to warm up your breasts. These really helped me when my milk first came in.
- Clogged Duct Relief – Legendairy Milk sunflower lecithin helped me and several friends loosen clogged ducts and then help prevent them. I took this daily after my first clogged duct.
- Help increase milk production – If you are struggling with your supply, I suggest trying Legendairy Milk Liquid Gold.
- Breast milk storage bags – I honestly haven’t had an issue with any other brands I’ve used. I like the price point of the Dr. Browns bags, so I buy them the most.
- Haaka – Yes, you really need one or two (I have two). Yes, they really work. When you get out of a hot shower and are leaking, you can just throw this on to catch the milk.
- Cheap Bottle Warmer – I have tried several, and this cheap one is my favorite. The Dr. Browns bottle warmer was terrible…Once you go to 100% formula, I cannot recommend the Baby Breeza enough. We love this thing. Now with baby number two, we have two of them, one in the kitchen and one in our bedroom.
- Sterilizer Bags – You’ll want these to sterilize new bottles, parts, pacifiers, etc. I also use them when traveling. There are cheap, and you can use each bag twenty times.
Softest PJ’s Ever – Bamboo Baby Clothes are worth every penny!
Do you have the Elvie Stride? I’d love to hear about your experience with it. Please leave a comment below.
Wednesday 7th of December 2022
Do you know if Elvie has different size flanges/breast shields? I see the Elvie Stride comes with 24mm flanges but I need 27mm ones. I use my Medela 27mm flanges on my Lanisoh manual pump and it fits great.
Sunday 22nd of January 2023
You can get a 28mm breast shield for the Elvie Stride here https://amzn.to/3kBXT8I
Monday 6th of June 2022
Hi! I used the Elvie original for both my first and second babies. I couldn't tolerate the Medela pumps, the original Elvie was way gentler for me and didn't make me cringe haha. The problem is with baby 2 I started to actually have a good supply since I was able to breastfeed as well and my let down was strong. It caused milk to get behind the green discs a lot and I had to use inserts to help which wasn't 100%. Do you know if the stride has this same issue of losing suction if your letdown gets behind any parts or is that not an issue with the stride set up?
Tuesday 21st of December 2021
Are you able to pump the same amount of milk from either pump? Do you find that because the Stride is stronger you pump more quantity?
Monday 3rd of January 2022
I get the same if not a little more with the Stride. It's hard to compare pumping sessions, it really depends on when your last pump was, did the baby nurse in between at all, did you drink/eat enough etc.
Monday 22nd of November 2021
For travel, is the original pump notably smaller since it doesn't have the separate pump? Or is the difference not that big of a deal?
Monday 6th of December 2021
For traveling and being more discrete the original pump is the better option.
Wednesday 17th of November 2021
How do you empty milk from the Elvie Stride?
Monday 6th of December 2021
You open the plastic spouts and move them to the side. In the video you can see me doing this.